Review roundup: The Retina iPad mini verdict is ‘pricey but best small tablet ever’


A Retina display may have been some time coming on the iPad mini, but the general verdict appears to be that it was worth the wait.

Many are querying the price, especially now that the full-size iPad Air is so much smaller and lighter than its predecessors, and costs just $100 more. But if portability is key, reviewers seem every bit as impressed by the iPad mini as I was by the Air.

Read on for the conclusions from five early reviews … 

Author Ad Placeholder
Will only appear on redesign env.

CNET bemoans the price and lack of Touch ID, but finds it otherwise perfect:

The good: The iPad Mini with Retina Display adds an excellent high-resolution display that rivals the iPad Air’s, a far faster A7 processor, and tops it off with improved Wi-Fi and LTE connectivity, with battery life that’s as good or better than in last year’s Mini.

The bad: A starting price of $399 places it well above the small-tablet competition, and adding more storage or LTE makes it even more expensive. It lacks the innovative Touch ID fingerprint sensor that the iPhone 5S sports.

The bottom line: The new iPad Mini somehow shrinks down the iPad Air into an even more compact package, sacrificing nearly nothing. It’s more expensive than before, but it’s also the perfect smaller tablet.

Gizmodo loves the screen, though not the speakers or the price:

This year’s iPad mini is, after a short time playing with it, picture perfect […]

Yep! There it is. That’s the one. The new iPad mini has finally, blessedly, gotten a display that can keep up with last year’s Android tablets. This is exactly what it should have been all along […]

The speaker placement is still terrible for doing anything that requires a landscape orientation. your palm can’t help but cover them up, everything is muffled, you can’t avoid it, it is bad […]

$400 for a 16GB model. That’s… disappointing. Especially since its direct competitors—with their own bright and shiny displays—are now more than $150 cheaper. That’s a lot of coin, especially for a feature that it should have had in the first place […] It may still not be a deal, but it’s finally free of any dealbreakers.

TechRadar also comments on the price, but thinks it ticks every box:

The original iPad mini blew us away, but we were also clear on the improvements we wanted to see, and Apple has taken steps to make the iPad mini 2 with Retina even more attractive.

Faster, prettier and more featured, the new iPad mini is everything we hoped it would be. Although there was nothing that we didn’t expect, it should be noted that this is a tablet that ticks every box.

The price is higher again as Apple, like Amazon and Google, looks to step away from the razor-thin margins of last year’s budget tablets, but on our early look alone, we think Apple has once again eased ahead in the mid-size slate space.

The Verge says it doesn’t matter whether you buy the Air or the mini, you can’t lose:

In talking to people about the new iPads, I’ve found everyone has an instinctive reaction — some people like the portability and smaller package of the mini, others appreciate the large screen of the Air. Some are price-conscious, others weight-conscious, others space-conscious, but everyone seems to lean one way or the other.

To those people, I say: go for it. You can’t lose. I’d buy a mini for myself, because I love having something that doesn’t take up much space in my bag and that I can wield even on a crowded subway. But the mini is now so beautiful and so immersive that you’ll never want to look away from the screen, and the Air now so portable and usable that you’ll rarely need to put it down. The mini used to be the lesser one, the reductive one, the one you bought if you couldn’t fit or afford the iPad. Now it’s just the smaller one.

Wired says Apple was late delivering an iPad mini with retina display, but that it’s what it was waiting for:

This is the iPad mini we’ve all been waiting for.

When the first generation iPad mini debuted last year, it was a terrific product. Apple’s first stab at a smaller tablet looked more far more elegant than the competition, managed to squeeze a larger 7.9-inch display in a traditionally 7-inch tablet form factor, and featured remarkable battery life. But its 1024 x 768 resolution display was a major let down compared to the Retina displays on the iPhone and full size iPad, as well as the growing number of HD screen-sporting Android tablets […]

The iPad mini is exactly the type of product we expect from Apple. Stunning good looks, a display so high resolution it’d take a magnifying glass to pick out the pixels, and unparalleled performance. This is the smaller iPad that should have debuted last year, but hey, better late than never.

If you’re having trouble tracking one down, the stock checker we linked to yesterday is still online at the time of writing. Your best deals will always be at or 9to5Mac product page and, obviously.

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and subscribe to our YouTube channel


  1. NQZ (@surgesoda) - 9 years ago

    Alright Ben, so now that the Retina Mini is out — would you still recommend the Air over the Retina Mini like you did in your previous Air review article?

  2. Clayton Batts - 9 years ago


  3. I suppose if you don’t care what OS your tablet is running or about build quality, etc, the iPad mini retina would seem expensive. If you want an Apple product running iOS, however, the iPad mini is a bargain. It’s the same under the hood as the iPad Air. Same chip, same camera, retina display, same battery life.

  4. Ipad air is cool, but ipad mini is much more portabile, i stay all day in my car cause of work, keep my ipad mini in the glove compartment and use it when i need to… Its just perfect :)

  5. Kenny Holmes - 9 years ago

    I have an ipad mini but didnt see gigantic difference between my ipad and the retina mini.

  6. Dennis McCarty - 9 years ago

    People forget to mention even though the Air and Mini2 have the same A7 chip, the Air is clocked the higher making it the fastest and highest scoring in geek bench scrores. The Mini2 has the same clock as the 5S.

    • ellzworth - 9 years ago

      No one can tell the difference between the iPad Mini’s 1.29GHz clock speed vs the iPad Air’s 1.39GHz speeds and the iPhone 5s’S 1.30GHz. Really, they can’t.

      • Ben Lovejoy - 9 years ago

        Agreed. Real-life, it’s utterly irrelevant.


Avatar for Ben Lovejoy Ben Lovejoy

Ben Lovejoy is a British technology writer and EU Editor for 9to5Mac. He’s known for his op-eds and diary pieces, exploring his experience of Apple products over time, for a more rounded review. He also writes fiction, with two technothriller novels, a couple of SF shorts and a rom-com!

Ben Lovejoy's favorite gear